Going to make this declaration right now. I’m always going to refer to Billy Batson as Captain Marvel. I don’t care about Carol Danvers and Marvel Comics, Billy had the name first. Besides, it wasn’t until the New 52 that they stopped referring to Billy as Captain Marvel in-universe. And we can all agree that the New 52 was dumb. Anyway, this 4 issue story released in 2006 and depicted the first time that Superman and Captain Marvel worked together.

This story obviously takes place in the early days of the main DC Universe. Before Diana left Themyscira for Man’s World, before Batman had been operating for a full year in Gotham, the heroes of Metropolis & Fawcett City find themselves working together. I should note that back in the 90s, Billy had his own series called “The Power of Shazam!” which was a followup to a graphic novel with the same name. The graphic novel re-established an origin for Billy Batson as Captain Marvel which would remain until the New 52. I bring this up because in-universe at the time, there was a 4 year gap between the graphic novel and the beginning of the follow-up series. “First Thunder” actually does a great job of filling in the gap between the two and doesn’t contradict anything established in those projects.

But now let’s talk about the story itself. Billy is homeless and living in the subway, and there is a friend from school who occasionally visits him and knows about his superhero identity. Billy is still getting used to the unspoken costs that come with being a superhero, but that isn’t seen until later. Billy is still having fun with his magical powers and does some genuine good for his city. Superman ends up running into Captain Marvel when he follows a group of museum thieves who can conjure up magical monsters. The two team-up and work on the case together to figure out what’s going on. We get a scene where they are in the North Pole, assumingely near the Fortress of Solitude, and Captain Marvel is just asking Superman questions. Asking about his powers and other similar fan questions. But to his credit, he does just simply come across as a big fan of Superman, if slightly annoying. Still fun to see a more relaxed scene of two superheroes talking, even if is short.

We do get a few flashbacks to an even that happened some time before the beginning of this story. Captain Marvel stops what was secretly a scheme of Dr. Sivana’s to collect insurance money. So Sivana ends up reaching out to Lex Luthor in an effort to deal with Captain Marvel. The two bald men meet and their opinion of the other is exactly what you expect. But it is still cool to see these two similar yet very different villains interact. Their meeting resulted in Sivana getting in touch of a metahuman tracker to tail Captain Marvel and find out some information about the magical hero.

In the main story, they end up discovering what the plan is. The museum thieves are planning on creating a demonic equivalent of Captain Marvel while another magical villain – Eclipso – is unleashed in Fawcett City. While Captain Marvel fights his demonic equivalent named Sabbac, Superman must deal with Eclipso and the mind controlled people he sues to throw at the Kryptonian. Both heroes end up winning and congratulate the other. Superman goes back to Metropolis and Billy meets his friend in the subway to look at a newspaper talking about Captain Marvel. However, the third issue ends with the two of them being ambushed by a group of mercenaries holding guns against the two kids.

And this is where the story takes a surprising turn. That metahuman tracker successfully followed Captain Marvel for a while and discovered that he was Billy and was living in the subway. Sivana then dispatches mercenaries to kill the kid known as Captain Marvel. While Billy is able to successfully transform and knock out all the gunmen…his friend lies dead behind him. The sight of it shocks Billy. We later see Captain Marvel force his way into the police station and physcially abuses one of the mercs in custody. Threatening to kill him if he doesn’t speak. Luckily Billy doesn’t kill the gunman. Cpatain Marvel shows up in Sivana’s office, terrifying him and holding the old man in hi hands. Letting Sivana know that he has been trying to come up with any reason to not kill him, but fails to find that reason. For a moment, it does look like Sivana will be murdered. But Billy finds he can’t just do it and lets the villain go before leaving Fawcett City.

Superman sees the news coverage of this in Metropolis and finds Captain Marvel at the same North Pole location from earlier. Superman expects a tense confrontation, maybe even a fight. But he is genuinely surprised to see the champion crying and regretful about what happened. He tries to explain how a kid died, someone he considered a close friend. This of course confuses Superman. Captain Marvel then stands in front of Superman, says the magic word, and he transforms into Billy Batson. A moment of silence passes, but then Superman asks five words, and I swear you can feel the quiet anger when you read the dialogue. “Who did this to you?”

This brings us to a meeting between Superman and the wizard Shazam, the person who gave Billy Batson his powers. We see Superman yell at the wizard, condemning him for choosing a child to take on such power and an incredibly large burden. Throughout most of the conversation, Shazam stands firm and insists that Billy was the right choice and it was his fate. Superman yells back, arguing back how kids should be in school and enjoying their lives without the worries that heroes must deal with. At least someone like Superman had time to process and think about the costs before he put on a cape, at least it was his decision. Billy isn’t able to process something like what just happened in the subway. Shazam admits that Billy is new to something like this, stating that he needs guidance. But the look on his face is s subtle silent plead to Superman to help Billy in this dark moment. Realizing that Shazam himself isn’t the best person to help him right now and that as powerful as he is, he also needs Superman’s help just as much as Billy. The story ends with Superman finding Billy in an abandoned home and sitting down next to him as he reveals his identity with the young kid and they begin a talk.

For three quarters of this story, it is a pretty good story. Fun to read with some cool action and small moments of fan service. But this final issue includes a hard tonal shift that works in favor of the mini-series. It elevates it into a story that holds a surprising amount of emotional weight. It gives a moment where it imparts an important lesson. Everyone experiences hardship, no matter how invincible you feel. It is hard and feels overwhelming if you face it along. But you shouldn’t face it alone. It is OK to reach out to someone for help. Because it’s our connections to others that make us feel like we can take on anything.